- To extend undue benefit to the accused civil servant — The provisions contained in E & D Rules and Special Powers Act, 2001 were not followed — No action is taken by the competent authority/Government against such Civil servants who are responsible for violating the mandatory provision of law/Rules — The point was not resolved by the Service Tribunal — Case remanded. Muhammad Bashir v. AJ&K Govt. & 5 others 2005 SCR 239 (A)